Intimidări și presiuni la adresa jurnaliștilor

Accesul la informațiile de interes public este un drept fundamental și un pilon esențial al democrației.

În ciuda acestui fapt, jurnaliștii continuă să fie ținta unor acțiuni de intimidare și a unor campanii de discreditare menite să submineze atât credibilitatea profesională a celor care, în ultimele luni, au expus abuzuri și declarații false din sistemul de justiție, cât și rolul presei ca instituție esențială într-o societate democratică.

Ne-am alăturat scrisorii adresate Comisiei Europene de către Alianța a Patra Putere, care documentează cele mai recente tentative de intimidare și presiune, și care solicită respectarea principiilor democratice privind protejarea pluralismului media și a libertății de exprimare.

Scrisoarea vine ca reacție la acțiunile de intimidare îndreptate împotriva jurnaliștilor care au publicat două investigații recente, temeinic documentate, și care au declanșat atacuri și încercări de subminare a credibilității jurnaliștilor.

Romania's Social Democratic Party (PSD) and Minister of Justice Intimidate Investigative Journalists in an EU Member State

We, the undersigned, address you as journalists and organizations supporting independent media in Romania in order to draw your attention to a serious and emblematic case of intimidation of investigative journalism in a Member State of the European Union.

Following the publication of a thoroughly documented investigation concerning serious suspicions of plagiarism in the doctoral thesis of Romania’s Minister of Justice, investigative journalist Emilia Șercan became the target of coordinated public attacks by the largest party in the governing coalition (PSD) and by the minister implicated by the investigation. These reactions do not refute the facts presented by the journalist; instead, they aim to delegitimize her work and discredit the profession itself.

The same delegitimization strategy was recently used in another investigation that triggered a strong reaction within Romanian society. The independent newsroom Recorder revealed, in a video documentary, fundamental deficiencies in Romania’s justice system. Once again, the authorities avoided addressing the documented facts and chose instead to attack the journalists and their alleged motivations.

We are facing a classic pattern of intimidation: rather than providing a factual response, political actors and state authorities accuse investigative journalism of alleged political motivations and affiliations, without presenting any evidence. This strategy, characteristic of illiberal regimes, is not merely intended to discourage investigations into the integrity of those in power, but represents a mechanism of systematic intimidation. Its purpose is to send a warning message to the entire press – that any journalist who dares to investigate those in power will be publicly punished.

We consider it extremely serious that a Minister of Justice and the ruling party to which he belongs – PSD – use their institutional position to attack a journalist and to question the legitimacy of the press to hold power to account. This constitutes a red line that cannot be crossed in a state governed by the rule of law, nor in a European Union founded on values that protect press freedom, pluralism, and democratic oversight of power.

These practices directly contravene European Union standards on freedom of expression and freedom of the press, enshrined in Article 11 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, as well as in the consistent case law of the European Court of Human Rights, which establishes that the press plays the essential role of a “watchdog” of democracy.

Attacking investigative journalists by public authorities, questioning the legitimacy of their work, and attributing alleged political motivations without evidence constitute forms of pressure that are incompatible with the obligations assumed by EU Member States regarding the protection of media pluralism and freedom of expression.

In this context, we ask you to:

  • examine this case as a serious potential example of a breach of European standards on press freedom and the rule of law;
  • request official explanations from the Romanian authorities regarding the attacks against investigative journalism;
  • closely monitor how the Government of Romania complies with its EU obligations concerning the protection of journalists;
  • send a clear and unequivocal public signal that intimidation, harassment, and media lynching of the press are not tolerated in a Member State of the European Union.

Silence or relativization of such abuses risks turning them into an acceptable practice. The solidarity of European institutions with investigative journalism is essential for the defense of the democratic values the European Union claims to uphold.

This letter is not merely an expression of support for a journalist; it is a firm appeal to defend press freedom as a cornerstone of the rule of law.

Signatories
  • The Fourth Estate Alliance (Alianța a Patra Putere)
  • ActiveWatch
  • Center for Independent Journalism (Centrul pentru Jurnalism Independent)
  • Association of Independent Journalists of Romania (Asociația Ziariștilor Independenți din România)
  • Timișoara Society (Societatea Timișoara)
  • Freedom House
  • International Alliance of Journalists in Romania (Alianța Internațională a Jurnaliștilor din România)
  • Faculty of Journalism and Communication Studies, University of Bucharest (Facultatea de Jurnalism și Științele Comunicării, Universitatea din București)
  • Funky Citizens 
Background

The Emilia Șercan Case (PressOne)

On 12 January 2026, journalist Emilia Șercan revealed that Romania’s Minister of Justice, Radu Marinescu (PSD), had plagiarized more than half of his doctoral thesis. Șercan, who has published investigations into plagiarism for over ten years, analyzed the entire thesis, publicly presented all evidence of academic fraud, and offered the Minister of Justice the right to present his point of view prior to publication.

After publication, both the Minister of Justice and PSD (the party to which he belongs) reacted publicly. They denied – without providing evidence or arguments – that the thesis was plagiarized and accused the journalist of having obscure motivations. In an official press release, PSD explicitly claimed that the exposure of the plagiarism was “an attempt to undermine the legal procedures regarding the appointment of chief prosecutors” and labeled the author of the investigation “an impostor.”

Emilia Șercan was threatened with death in 2019 by the leadership of the Police Academy, who were later definitively convicted for instigation to blackmail. In 2022, a kompromat operation was orchestrated against her after she revealed the plagiarism of the then–Prime Minister, Nicolae Ciucă. She is a lecturer at the Faculty of Journalism and Communication Studies, University of Bucharest.

She was nominated in 2025 for the “PRIX EUROPA European Journalist of the Year 2024” and in 2023 for the #AllforJan award, granted in memory of Slovak journalist Ján Kuciak, murdered in 2018. She was also awarded the Services to Academic Integrity Award by the European Network for Academic Integrity (ENAI) in 2019, and in 2020 the United States Embassy in Romania granted her the International Anti-Corruption Day Award.

The Andreea Pocotilă & Mihai Voinea Case (Recorder)

On 9 December 2025, Recorder broadcast a two-hour documentary titled “Captured Justice” (Justiție capturată). Based on 18 months of investigation, Andreea Pocotilă and Mihai Voinea presented complex and opaque mechanisms – largely unknown to the public – through which criminal cases involving powerful and influential figures are delayed until the statute of limitations expires.

Additionally, the documentary provided an overview of how, following legislative changes introduced in 2022 by the political authorities, a small group of individuals came to control the functioning of the judiciary – particularly appellate courts and specialized prosecutors’ offices dealing with anti-corruption and organized crime.

After the broadcast, nearly 900 magistrates publicly expressed solidarity with judges and prosecutors who had the courage to expose problems and pressures within the justice system. The public responded with street protests in several cities, open letters, and petitions.

Judges from the Superior Council of Magistracy (CSM) issued a statement claiming that the documentary amplified a campaign to “destabilize the judiciary by destroying public trust in the justice system” and referred to a “well-established plan.” The President of the Bucharest Court of Appeal publicly accused both the Recorder journalists and the public television broadcaster – which rebroadcast the documentary – of public incitement against the constitutional order (a criminal offense); she attacked the magistrates interviewed by Recorder and claimed that the newsroom had not offered her the right of reply. (In reality, the Court of Appeal refused Recorder’s request for a filmed interview made 21 days prior to publication. The written refusal was made public by Recorder.)

To date, neither the President of the Bucharest Court of Appeal nor the CSM has contested any of the evidence or filmed statements on which Recorder based its investigation. The documentary “Captured Justice” has reached 5 million views – over a quarter of Romania’s population – on YouTube alone.